Days to Expiry — Option Selling Analyzer logo
Days to Expiry
Option Selling Analyzer
← Back to all articles

Dec 3, 2025

Naked Puts vs Cash-Secured Puts: Margin Strategy Comparison

Compare naked puts (margin-based) vs cash-secured puts. Learn capital efficiency trade-offs, risk profiles, margin requirements, and when each strategy makes sense for your account.

Both naked puts and cash-secured puts collect premium from selling put options. The key difference? Capital tied up.

With a cash-secured put, you reserve the full strike price × 100 in cash. With a naked put, you use margin and only need 20-30% of that capital.

This creates a fundamental trade-off: Capital efficiency vs. risk management simplicity.

Let's break down both strategies so you can choose which fits your style.

Loading strategy analyzer…

Quick Income Calculator

See how much you could earn with cash-secured puts:

Monthly Income Calculator

Estimate income from selling covered calls or cash-secured puts

$180.00
Monthly Income
$744.20
Annual Yield
50.3%
Breakeven
$172.55
Buffer
4.1%
Strike: $183.60
Premium/contract: $745.20
Contracts: 1
Open in Strategy Analyzer

Estimates based on simplified Black-Scholes. Actual premiums depend on live market conditions, liquidity, and bid-ask spreads. Verify in Strategy Analyzer.

Naked Puts: The Margin Version

A naked put means you sell a put without reserving full capital. Your broker uses margin (borrowed money) to cover potential assignment.

Example (Naked put on Apple):

  • AAPL at $230
  • Sell $220 put (30 DTE) for $2.00
  • Premium collected: $200
  • Margin requirement: ~$5,000 (20% of $220 strike × 100)
  • Capital tied up: Only $5,000
  • If assigned: You owe $22,000 to buy 100 shares (margin takes the rest)

ROI on margin:

  • $200 profit on $5,000 tied up = 4% return in 30 days
  • Annualized: 48% return

Cash-Secured Puts: The Conservative Version

A cash-secured put means you reserve the full amount in cash.

Same example (Cash-secured put):

  • AAPL at $230
  • Sell $220 put (30 DTE) for $2.00
  • Premium collected: $200
  • Cash reserved: $22,000
  • Capital tied up: $22,000 (fully reserved)
  • If assigned: You buy 100 shares, cash pays for it

ROI on cash:

  • $200 profit on $22,000 tied up = 0.9% return in 30 days
  • Annualized: 10.8% return

Side-by-Side Comparison

FactorNaked PutCash-Secured PutWinner
Capital required20% ($5K)100% ($22K)Naked
ROI (monthly)4%0.9%Naked
Margin interestYes (~4-8%/yr)NoCSP
Risk on assignmentMargin call riskNone (cash ready)CSP
Assignment mechanicsMargin handles itSimple (cash pays)CSP
Broker requirementsLevel 2+ optionsStandard accountCSP
Stress/managementHigher (margin tracked)Lower (simple)CSP
Best forExperienced tradersBeginnersContext-dependent

Broker Requirements and Margin Levels

Options Approval Levels:

  • Level 1: Long calls/puts only (no selling)
  • Level 2: Short calls/puts (requires approval)
  • Level 3: Spreads, covered calls (naked puts here)
  • Level 4: Spreads, any combination (very flexible)

Naked puts require minimum Level 2 options approval.

Cash requirements vary by broker:

  • Interactive Brokers: 20% of strike (tight)
  • Td Ameritrade/Schwab: 25-30% of strike
  • Fidelity: 25% of strike

Lower broker margins = more capital efficiency = more traders get approved

Capital Efficiency: The Math

Assume you have $100,000 account.

With Cash-Secured Puts:

  • Sell 4 puts at $220 strike (AAPL-like)
  • Capital per put: $22,000 × 4 = $88,000 total
  • Remaining cash: $12,000
  • Can run 4 puts simultaneously
  • If all assigned: $88,000 tied up in stock

With Naked Puts:

  • Sell 20 puts at $220 strike
  • Margin per put: $5,000 × 20 = $100,000 buying power
  • Can run 20 puts simultaneously
  • If all assigned: Massive margin call ($420,000 owed)

Reality check: Most traders never assign all positions. But the potential shows the risk/reward:

  • CSP: Conservative, capital-efficient with limit
  • Naked: Aggressive, capital-efficient at scale but assignment risk

The Assignment Scenario: Margin Call Risk

Example: Naked put, market crash

  • You sold 10 naked $220 AAPL puts on margin
  • Margin requirement: $5,000 per put × 10 = $50,000
  • Your account equity: $100,000
  • Used buying power: $50,000
  • Available cushion: $50,000

Black swan event:

  • AAPL crashes to $150 (gap down on bad news)
  • All 10 puts are assigned ($22,000 each)
  • You now owe $220,000 for 1,000 shares
  • Margin loan needed: $220,000

Margin call calculation:

  • Account now has: -$120,000 (negative, owing money)
  • Your stocks are worth: $150,000 (AAPL at $150)
  • Maintenance margin required: 25-30% = $55,000-$66,000
  • Your equity is: $30,000 (not enough)
  • Result: Margin call → Broker force-closes positions

With cash-secured puts:

  • You sold 4 CSPs at $220 strike
  • Cash reserved: $88,000
  • AAPL crashes to $150
  • All 4 assigned: You own 400 shares at $220, paid from cash
  • Cost: $88,000 (your cash absorbs it)
  • No margin call, no forced liquidation
  • You simply own 400 shares at $220 average

Margin Interest Cost

If you're using margin to fund naked puts, you're paying interest on the borrowed amount.

Margin interest typical rates:

  • Interactive Brokers: 2-4% annually
  • TD Ameritrade: 7-9% annually
  • Schwab: 8-10% annually

Example cost:

  • Naked puts require $50,000 margin
  • Margin interest: 5% annually = $2,500/year
  • Puts profit: $200 × 4 puts × 12 months = $9,600
  • After margin interest: $9,600 - $2,500 = $7,100 net

Better broker choice: Interactive Brokers offers lower margin rates (2-4% vs 8-10%), making naked puts more profitable.

When Naked Puts Make Sense

Scenario 1: Experienced Trader, High Conviction

  • You've been selling CSPs for 2+ years
  • Comfortable with margin mechanics
  • Want to amplify returns

Example: Switch from 4 CSPs → 10 naked puts, triple your premium with 3x capital

Scenario 2: Short Holding Period

  • Sell puts with very tight strikes (delta 0.80+)
  • High probability of profit without assignment
  • Naked put likely expires worthless

Example:

  • 5 days before assignment, stock at $225
  • $220 naked put expires worthless
  • Never used margin, freed it up for next trade

Scenario 3: Large Account with Insurance

  • Account: $500,000+
  • Can absorb assignment risk
  • Sophisticated margin management

When CSP is Better

Scenario 1: You're New to Options

  • Building experience
  • Want to understand assignment without complexity
  • Margin adds unnecessary stress

Better: Start with CSPs (5-10 contracts), graduate to naked puts after 1 year

Scenario 2: You Want Simplicity

  • Assignment = cash already set aside
  • No margin call risk
  • Sleep well at night

Example: $100K account, sell 4 CSPs, collect $800/month = 9.6% annual

Scenario 3: Assignment Keeps You Disciplined

  • CSP assignment forces you to own stock
  • Wheel strategy becomes natural (sell covered calls next)
  • Accountability built in

Tax Implications: No Difference

Both naked and cash-secured puts are taxed identically:

  • Premium collected = ordinary income (tax year collected)
  • If assigned = cost basis equals strike price
  • Capital gain/loss calculated from strike

No tax advantage to either strategy. Choose based on risk/capital, not taxes.

Hybrid Approach: Mix of Both

Many professional traders use both:

Portfolio example ($100K account):

  • 4 CSPs on high-quality stocks ($88K reserved)
  • 4 naked puts on highly probable stocks ($20K margin)
  • Total monthly premium: $400 (CSP) + $200 (naked) = $600
  • Capital used: $88K + margin interest

Benefits:

  • CSPs provide consistent income (low stress)
  • Naked puts boost returns on liquid, tight-delta positions
  • Diversification between methods

Platform Mechanics: How Brokers Handle Each

Interactive Brokers (Most Efficient)

  • Naked puts: 20% margin (lowest)
  • CSP: Full cash reserve option
  • Margin interest: 2-4% (lowest)
  • Verdict: Best for active naked put traders

Schwab / TD Ameritrade (Balanced)

  • Naked puts: 25-30% margin
  • CSP: Full cash reserve option
  • Margin interest: 8-10%
  • Verdict: Good for both strategies

Fidelity (Conservative)

  • Naked puts: 25% margin
  • CSP: Full cash reserve option
  • Margin interest: 9-10%
  • Verdict: Better for CSP strategy (simple)

Real Comparison: 6-Month Results

Setup: $100,000 account, 6-month period

CSP Strategy

  • Sell 4 puts at $220 strike, 30 DTE monthly
  • Monthly premium: $400 (avg $100/put)
  • 6 months: $2,400 total
  • Assignments: 1 (buy 100 shares at $220)
  • After assignment: Sell covered call, generate $300 more
  • 6-month total profit: $2,700
  • ROI: 2.7%

Naked Put Strategy

  • Sell 10 puts at $220 strike, 30 DTE monthly
  • Monthly premium: $1,000 (avg $100/put)
  • Margin interest: -$125/month = -$750 for 6 months
  • 6 months: $1,000 × 6 - $750 = $5,250 profit
  • Assignments: 2 (margin handles buyback)
  • 6-month total profit: $5,250
  • ROI: 5.25%

Naked puts nearly 2x return, but requires:

  • Margin approval
  • Tolerance for leverage
  • Ability to manage margin calls
  • Lower margin broker (IB better than Schwab)

Common Mistakes

  1. Selling naked puts without understanding margin calls

    • Market crashes 20%, forced liquidation at worst time
    • Better: Paper trade naked puts first, understand mechanics

  2. Ignoring margin interest costs

    • Use expensive broker (8-10% interest)
    • Margin interest eats half your profits
    • Better: Use Interactive Brokers (2-4% interest)

  3. Overleveraging with naked puts

    • Sell 20 naked puts on $50K account
    • Any market move = margin call
    • Better: Limit to 5-10 naked puts max on $50K account

  4. Mixing CSP and naked puts haphazardly

    • No clear system, don't know total margin usage
    • Better: Dedicated buckets (CSP section, naked section)

Decision Framework

Choose Cash-Secured Puts if:

  • You're new to options (<2 years)
  • You want simplicity and sleep well at night
  • Account <$100K (CSP capital efficient enough)
  • You prefer disciplined assignment forcing you to hold stock

Choose Naked Puts if:

  • You have 2+ years options trading experience
  • Comfortable with margin and margin call mechanics
  • Account >$100K
  • You use a low-margin broker (Interactive Brokers)
  • You want max capital efficiency
  • You're okay with forced liquidation risk

Choose Hybrid if:

  • You want best of both worlds
  • Experienced trader with emotional discipline
  • Account >$50K
  • You can manage separate CSP and naked buckets

Related Articles

Within Cluster: