Both naked puts and cash-secured puts collect premium from selling put options. The key difference? Capital tied up.
With a cash-secured put, you reserve the full strike price × 100 in cash. With a naked put, you use margin and only need 20-30% of that capital.
This creates a fundamental trade-off: Capital efficiency vs. risk management simplicity.
Let's break down both strategies so you can choose which fits your style.
Naked Puts: The Margin Version
A naked put means you sell a put without reserving full capital. Your broker uses margin (borrowed money) to cover potential assignment.
Example (Naked put on Apple):
- AAPL at $230
- Sell $220 put (30 DTE) for $2.00
- Premium collected: $200
- Margin requirement: ~$5,000 (20% of $220 strike × 100)
- Capital tied up: Only $5,000
- If assigned: You owe $22,000 to buy 100 shares (margin takes the rest)
ROI on margin:
- $200 profit on $5,000 tied up = 4% return in 30 days
- Annualized: 48% return
Cash-Secured Puts: The Conservative Version
A cash-secured put means you reserve the full amount in cash.
Same example (Cash-secured put):
- AAPL at $230
- Sell $220 put (30 DTE) for $2.00
- Premium collected: $200
- Cash reserved: $22,000
- Capital tied up: $22,000 (fully reserved)
- If assigned: You buy 100 shares, cash pays for it
ROI on cash:
- $200 profit on $22,000 tied up = 0.9% return in 30 days
- Annualized: 10.8% return
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Factor | Naked Put | Cash-Secured Put | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Capital required | 20% ($5K) | 100% ($22K) | Naked |
| ROI (monthly) | 4% | 0.9% | Naked |
| Margin interest | Yes (~4-8%/yr) | No | CSP |
| Risk on assignment | Margin call risk | None (cash ready) | CSP |
| Assignment mechanics | Margin handles it | Simple (cash pays) | CSP |
| Broker requirements | Level 2+ options | Standard account | CSP |
| Stress/management | Higher (margin tracked) | Lower (simple) | CSP |
| Best for | Experienced traders | Beginners | Context-dependent |
Broker Requirements and Margin Levels
Options Approval Levels:
- Level 1: Long calls/puts only (no selling)
- Level 2: Short calls/puts (requires approval)
- Level 3: Spreads, covered calls (naked puts here)
- Level 4: Spreads, any combination (very flexible)
Naked puts require minimum Level 2 options approval.
Cash requirements vary by broker:
- Interactive Brokers: 20% of strike (tight)
- Td Ameritrade/Schwab: 25-30% of strike
- Fidelity: 25% of strike
Lower broker margins = more capital efficiency = more traders get approved
Capital Efficiency: The Math
Assume you have $100,000 account.
With Cash-Secured Puts:
- Sell 4 puts at $220 strike (AAPL-like)
- Capital per put: $22,000 × 4 = $88,000 total
- Remaining cash: $12,000
- Can run 4 puts simultaneously
- If all assigned: $88,000 tied up in stock
With Naked Puts:
- Sell 20 puts at $220 strike
- Margin per put: $5,000 × 20 = $100,000 buying power
- Can run 20 puts simultaneously
- If all assigned: Massive margin call ($420,000 owed)
Reality check: Most traders never assign all positions. But the potential shows the risk/reward:
- CSP: Conservative, capital-efficient with limit
- Naked: Aggressive, capital-efficient at scale but assignment risk
The Assignment Scenario: Margin Call Risk
Example: Naked put, market crash
- You sold 10 naked $220 AAPL puts on margin
- Margin requirement: $5,000 per put × 10 = $50,000
- Your account equity: $100,000
- Used buying power: $50,000
- Available cushion: $50,000
Black swan event:
- AAPL crashes to $150 (gap down on bad news)
- All 10 puts are assigned ($22,000 each)
- You now owe $220,000 for 1,000 shares
- Margin loan needed: $220,000
Margin call calculation:
- Account now has: -$120,000 (negative, owing money)
- Your stocks are worth: $150,000 (AAPL at $150)
- Maintenance margin required: 25-30% = $55,000-$66,000
- Your equity is: $30,000 (not enough)
- Result: Margin call → Broker force-closes positions
With cash-secured puts:
- You sold 4 CSPs at $220 strike
- Cash reserved: $88,000
- AAPL crashes to $150
- All 4 assigned: You own 400 shares at $220, paid from cash
- Cost: $88,000 (your cash absorbs it)
- No margin call, no forced liquidation
- You simply own 400 shares at $220 average
Margin Interest Cost
If you're using margin to fund naked puts, you're paying interest on the borrowed amount.
Margin interest typical rates:
- Interactive Brokers: 2-4% annually
- TD Ameritrade: 7-9% annually
- Schwab: 8-10% annually
Example cost:
- Naked puts require $50,000 margin
- Margin interest: 5% annually = $2,500/year
- Puts profit: $200 × 4 puts × 12 months = $9,600
- After margin interest: $9,600 - $2,500 = $7,100 net
Better broker choice: Interactive Brokers offers lower margin rates (2-4% vs 8-10%), making naked puts more profitable.
When Naked Puts Make Sense
Scenario 1: Experienced Trader, High Conviction
- You've been selling CSPs for 2+ years
- Comfortable with margin mechanics
- Want to amplify returns
Example: Switch from 4 CSPs → 10 naked puts, triple your premium with 3x capital
Scenario 2: Short Holding Period
- Sell puts with very tight strikes (delta 0.80+)
- High probability of profit without assignment
- Naked put likely expires worthless
Example:
- 5 days before assignment, stock at $225
- $220 naked put expires worthless
- Never used margin, freed it up for next trade
Scenario 3: Large Account with Insurance
- Account: $500,000+
- Can absorb assignment risk
- Sophisticated margin management
When CSP is Better
Scenario 1: You're New to Options
- Building experience
- Want to understand assignment without complexity
- Margin adds unnecessary stress
Better: Start with CSPs (5-10 contracts), graduate to naked puts after 1 year
Scenario 2: You Want Simplicity
- Assignment = cash already set aside
- No margin call risk
- Sleep well at night
Example: $100K account, sell 4 CSPs, collect $800/month = 9.6% annual
Scenario 3: Assignment Keeps You Disciplined
- CSP assignment forces you to own stock
- Wheel strategy becomes natural (sell covered calls next)
- Accountability built in
Tax Implications: No Difference
Both naked and cash-secured puts are taxed identically:
- Premium collected = ordinary income (tax year collected)
- If assigned = cost basis equals strike price
- Capital gain/loss calculated from strike
No tax advantage to either strategy. Choose based on risk/capital, not taxes.
Hybrid Approach: Mix of Both
Many professional traders use both:
Portfolio example ($100K account):
- 4 CSPs on high-quality stocks ($88K reserved)
- 4 naked puts on highly probable stocks ($20K margin)
- Total monthly premium: $400 (CSP) + $200 (naked) = $600
- Capital used: $88K + margin interest
Benefits:
- CSPs provide consistent income (low stress)
- Naked puts boost returns on liquid, tight-delta positions
- Diversification between methods
Platform Mechanics: How Brokers Handle Each
Interactive Brokers (Most Efficient)
- Naked puts: 20% margin (lowest)
- CSP: Full cash reserve option
- Margin interest: 2-4% (lowest)
- Verdict: Best for active naked put traders
Schwab / TD Ameritrade (Balanced)
- Naked puts: 25-30% margin
- CSP: Full cash reserve option
- Margin interest: 8-10%
- Verdict: Good for both strategies
Fidelity (Conservative)
- Naked puts: 25% margin
- CSP: Full cash reserve option
- Margin interest: 9-10%
- Verdict: Better for CSP strategy (simple)
Real Comparison: 6-Month Results
Setup: $100,000 account, 6-month period
CSP Strategy
- Sell 4 puts at $220 strike, 30 DTE monthly
- Monthly premium: $400 (avg $100/put)
- 6 months: $2,400 total
- Assignments: 1 (buy 100 shares at $220)
- After assignment: Sell covered call, generate $300 more
- 6-month total profit: $2,700
- ROI: 2.7%
Naked Put Strategy
- Sell 10 puts at $220 strike, 30 DTE monthly
- Monthly premium: $1,000 (avg $100/put)
- Margin interest: -$125/month = -$750 for 6 months
- 6 months: $1,000 × 6 - $750 = $5,250 profit
- Assignments: 2 (margin handles buyback)
- 6-month total profit: $5,250
- ROI: 5.25%
Naked puts nearly 2x return, but requires:
- Margin approval
- Tolerance for leverage
- Ability to manage margin calls
- Lower margin broker (IB better than Schwab)
Common Mistakes
-
Selling naked puts without understanding margin calls
- Market crashes 20%, forced liquidation at worst time
- Better: Paper trade naked puts first, understand mechanics
-
Ignoring margin interest costs
- Use expensive broker (8-10% interest)
- Margin interest eats half your profits
- Better: Use Interactive Brokers (2-4% interest)
-
Overleveraging with naked puts
- Sell 20 naked puts on $50K account
- Any market move = margin call
- Better: Limit to 5-10 naked puts max on $50K account
-
Mixing CSP and naked puts haphazardly
- No clear system, don't know total margin usage
- Better: Dedicated buckets (CSP section, naked section)
Decision Framework
Choose Cash-Secured Puts if:
- You're new to options (<2 years)
- You want simplicity and sleep well at night
- Account <$100K (CSP capital efficient enough)
- You prefer disciplined assignment forcing you to hold stock
Choose Naked Puts if:
- You have 2+ years options trading experience
- Comfortable with margin and margin call mechanics
- Account >$100K
- You use a low-margin broker (Interactive Brokers)
- You want max capital efficiency
- You're okay with forced liquidation risk
Choose Hybrid if:
- You want best of both worlds
- Experienced trader with emotional discipline
- Account >$50K
- You can manage separate CSP and naked buckets
Related Articles
Within Cluster: