The 21 DTE Rule Explained: When and Why to Close Options Positions Early

Every options seller faces the same dilemma: when should you close a winning trade? Take profits too early, and you leave money on the table. Wait too long, and a comfortable winner can evaporate overnight.

Enter the 21 DTE rule—a mechanical exit strategy that removes emotion from the decision entirely. Popularized by the research team at TastyTrade, this approach has become a cornerstone of systematic options selling. But why 21 days? And does the data actually support it?

This guide breaks down exactly how the 21 DTE rule works, the mechanics behind it, and when you should (and shouldn't) apply it to your own trades.

What Is the 21 DTE Rule?

The 21 DTE rule states that options sellers should close or roll their positions when they reach 21 days to expiration (DTE), regardless of current profit or loss.

DTE measures how many days remain until an option contract expires. A position opened with 45 days to expiration would hit the 21 DTE threshold roughly 24 days into the trade. At this point, the rule dictates an action: either take profits, cut losses, or roll to a new expiration cycle.

The rule applies primarily to short options strategies:

• Cash-secured puts
• Covered calls
• Credit spreads
• Iron condors
• Naked calls and puts

The key principle? Time is no longer your friend once you cross the 21-day threshold.

Why 21 Days? The Gamma Risk Explosion

To understand the 21 DTE rule, you need to understand gamma—the rate at which an option's delta changes as the underlying stock price moves.

Gamma is relatively stable during the first half of an option's life. A $1 move in the underlying might change your delta by a predictable amount. But as expiration approaches, gamma accelerates non-linearly. The curve gets steeper, and smaller price movements create larger swings in your position's value.

Here's what this means in practice:

Days to Expiration	Gamma Behavior	Risk Level
45-30 DTE	Low and stable	Manageable
30-21 DTE	Beginning to accelerate	Elevated
21-0 DTE	Exponential increase	High
7-0 DTE	Extreme sensitivity	Very high

At 21 DTE, gamma risk begins to dominate your position. A stock that moves 2% against you can wipe out weeks of theta decay in a single session. The mathematical edge that options sellers enjoy—capturing time decay—starts working against them as price risk overwhelms time decay benefits.

Research from TastyTrade's proprietary backtesting showed that positions held past 21 DTE experienced significantly higher volatility in returns, with the worst outcomes clustering in the final three weeks before expiration.

The Data Behind the Rule

TastyTrade's research team analyzed thousands of short options trades across different timeframes. Their findings consistently showed that closing at 21 DTE improved risk-adjusted returns compared to holding until expiration.

Key findings from their studies:

• Win rate stability: Trades closed at 21 DTE maintained more consistent win rates than those held to expiration
• Reduced tail risk: The worst single-trade losses occurred disproportionately in the final 21 days
• Sharpe ratio improvement: Risk-adjusted returns favored the 21 DTE exit across most underlying assets
• Assignment risk mitigation: Early closing avoids the scramble of expiration week assignment logistics

Importantly, the research also showed that holding slightly past 21 DTE—say to 14 or 7 DTE—didn't provide enough additional premium to justify the dramatically increased risk. The risk/reward curve simply breaks down in that final stretch.

21 DTE Rule vs. 50% Profit Target

Many options traders use a 50% profit target rule: close the position when you've captured 50% of the maximum potential profit. This is another valid mechanical exit, but it creates an interesting decision tree when combined with 21 DTE.

Scenario 1: You reach 50% profit before 21 DTE

• Most traders close immediately and redeploy capital
• The 21 DTE rule becomes irrelevant for this trade

Scenario 2: You reach 21 DTE without hitting 50% profit

• This is where the 21 DTE rule takes precedence
• Close the position even if you're only at 20%, 30%, or 40% profit

Scenario 3: The position is losing at 21 DTE

• Close or roll to the next expiration cycle
• Don't let a small loss become a large one due to gamma acceleration

Some traders combine both rules: aim for 50% profit, but enforce a hard stop at 21 DTE regardless of profit level. This hybrid approach maximizes the benefits of both time-based and profit-based exits.

When to Break the Rule

No trading rule should be followed blindly. There are legitimate scenarios where holding past 21 DTE makes sense:

Deep Out-of-the-Money Positions

If your short put is 15% out-of-the-money with 21 days remaining, the probability of assignment is extremely low. Some traders will let these ride to capture additional theta, especially if implied volatility remains elevated.

Earnings or Events Past 21 DTE

If you sold options through an earnings announcement that occurs at, say, 15 DTE, you've already accepted the event risk. Closing at 21 DTE would mean missing the volatility crush that typically benefits options sellers after earnings.

Wide-Ranging Strategies

Iron condors and defined-risk spreads sometimes benefit from letting the profitable side expire worthless while managing the tested side. The defined risk creates a different risk profile than naked options.

Tax Considerations

In taxable accounts, traders may hold positions into the next calendar year for tax deferral, or hold slightly longer to achieve long-term capital gains treatment on the underlying in covered call strategies.

Interactive Assignment Risk Calculator

Test how assignment risk changes as you approach expiration:

---

Practical Implementation

Implementing the 21 DTE rule requires discipline and systems. Here's how to put it into practice:

Set Calendar Alerts

Add calendar reminders for each open position 2-3 days before it hits 21 DTE. This gives you time to analyze whether to close, roll, or adjust.

Use Broker Automation

Most brokers support good-til-canceled (GTC) orders. While you can't automate the 21 DTE rule directly, you can set alerts or use third-party tools that monitor DTE and notify you when thresholds are reached.

Plan Your Roll Strategy

Decide in advance how you'll handle 21 DTE for each position type. Common approaches:

• Close and reopen: Take profits/losses and enter a new position 30-45 DTE
• Roll out: Buy back the current position and sell the next expiration cycle at the same strike
• Roll out and up/down: Adjust strikes if the underlying has moved significantly

Track the Metrics

Monitor whether following the 21 DTE rule actually improves your results. Track:

• Win rate at 21 DTE exits vs. hold-to-expiration
• Average profit/loss per trade
• Maximum adverse excursion (how far trades move against you)
• Time in trade (opportunity cost of capital)

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Even with a simple rule, execution errors can undermine the strategy:

Ignoring the rule during volatility spikes: High VIX environments are exactly when gamma risk is most dangerous. This is not the time to hold past 21 DTE hoping for mean reversion.

Rolling endlessly: Rolling at 21 DTE can become a way of avoiding losses. If a position is consistently tested, consider whether your strike selection or position sizing needs adjustment rather than perpetually rolling.

Forgetting about commissions: Frequent closing and rolling increases transaction costs. Ensure your commission structure supports active management, or adjust the rule to be less frequent.

Applying it to long options: The 21 DTE rule is designed for short options positions. Long options behave differently, and holding through expiration may be the entire point of the trade.

The Bottom Line

The 21 DTE rule isn't magic—it's risk management. By closing positions before gamma risk accelerates, you sacrifice a small amount of potential profit for significantly reduced tail risk and more predictable outcomes.

The rule works because it enforces discipline in an environment where emotions run high. When a trade is working, greed tempts you to hold longer. When it's not working, hope tempts you to wait for recovery. The 21 DTE rule removes both temptations with a simple, time-based trigger.

For systematic options sellers, this rule (or a variation of it) belongs in your trading plan. Start with strict adherence, track your results, and adjust based on your specific strategy, risk tolerance, and market conditions.

The best exit strategy is the one you'll actually follow—and the 21 DTE rule's simplicity makes it one of the most followable rules in options trading.

---

Want to learn more about DTE selection for specific strategies? Check out our guide on [best DTE for credit spreads](TODO: link) and how to compare [30 DTE vs 45 DTE](TODO: link) for different market environments.