Choosing a broker is the decision that shapes your entire trading life. A bad broker can cost you 10-20% annually in commissions, spreads, and missed fills. A good one saves you time, capital, and stress.
But "best" doesn't mean "most popular." The best broker for a day trader is garbage for an income trader. The best broker for spreads might suck for wheel strategies.
Let me walk you through the options and show you how to choose.
Already with IBKR? Enhance your Interactive Brokers experience with our IB Portfolio Analyzer for trade tracking and P&L analysis, or use our Chrome Extension for real-time portfolio monitoring directly in your browser.
The Broker Comparison Matrix
Here's how the major platforms stack up across income trading priorities:
| Feature | Interactive Brokers | Charles Schwab (TD) | Tastyworks | Cboe | IBKR Lite |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Commission (per contract) | $0-1 | $0-2 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Options Greeks | Excellent | Good | Excellent | Good | Basic |
| DTE Filtering | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No |
| Spreads Support | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Minimum Account | $0 | $0 | $2,000 | Varies | $0 |
| Platform Learning Curve | Steep | Moderate | Easy | Steep | Moderate |
| Best For | Pro traders | Casual traders | Income traders | Index traders | Beginners |
| Margin Rates | 2-3% | 3-4% | 2.5% | Varies | 3-4% |
| Dividend Reinvestment | Good | Excellent | Limited | N/A | Good |
Deep Dive: Each Platform
1. Interactive Brokers (Best for Advanced Traders)
Who it's for: Professionals, active traders, strategies traders with large accounts
Commissions:
- $0-1 per contract (volume discounts available)
- Stocks: $0.005 per share ($1 minimum)
- Net result: Cheapest long-term, but account minimums are steep
Greeks & Tools:
- Built-in Greeks display (delta, gamma, theta, vega all visible)
- P&L charts with Greeks sensitivity
- Portfolio heat map (shows portfolio Greeks at a glance)
- Excellent for analyzing multi-leg spreads
DTE Management:
- Excellent filtering by DTE
- Can set alerts on specific DTE windows (e.g., alert when 21 DTE is hit)
- Customizable watch lists by expiration
Pros:
- Lowest commissions (especially at volume)
- Most powerful Greeks tools
- Best margin rates (2-3%)
- Ideal for spread traders, wheel strategies, PMCCs
Cons:
- Steep learning curve (platform is overwhelming)
- Minimum account: $10,000+
- Customer support can be slow
- Commission structure takes time to understand
Best strategy: Wheel, PMCC, spreads, high-volume trading
Verdict: If you have $20K+ and plan to trade actively, IBKR is the clear winner. The Greeks tools and margin rates pay for themselves.
2. Charles Schwab (Best for Most Traders)
Who it's for: Casual to active traders, buy-and-hold with income strategies, account consolidation
Commissions:
- $0 per contract
- $0 per share
- Net result: Free everything
Greeks & Tools:
- Good Greeks display (delta, theta, vega, gamma)
- P&L simulator (helpful for understanding scenarios)
- Screening and stock research (integrated)
- Less powerful than IBKR but easier to use
DTE Management:
- Can filter by DTE
- Mobile alerts available
- Integration with financial planning tools
Pros:
- Zero commissions
- Great customer support
- Integrated banking (deposit/withdraw easy)
- Easy-to-use platform
- Excellent for beginners
- Strong research tools
Cons:
- Margin rates higher than IBKR (3-4%)
- Greeks tools less detailed than IBKR
- Platform less customizable
- Can be slower for power users
Best strategy: Covered calls, CSPs, introductory wheel trading
Verdict: If you have $5-20K and want simplicity, Schwab is the obvious choice. Zero commissions and great service mean you're not nickel-and-dimed.
3. Tastyworks (Best for Income Traders)
Who it's for: Income-focused traders, spreads specialists, short volatility traders
Commissions:
- $0 per contract (credit spreads)
- $0-1 on debit spreads
- Net result: Free for most income trades
Greeks & Tools:
- Excellent Greeks visualization
- "Greeks bands" (shows probability of profit zones visually)
- IV Rank and IV Percentile built-in
- P&L analytics specific to income strategies
- "Analyze" tab shows Greeks across a range of stock prices
DTE Management:
- Excellent DTE filtering
- Can sort by DTE directly
- Alerts available for specific DTE windows
- Ideal for high-volume short-option management
Pros:
- Zero commissions on spreads (massive for spreads traders)
- Best Greeks visualization for probability
- Dedicated "Tastytrade" education content
- Community focus
- IV tools are unmatched
- Ideal for managing 10+ concurrent positions
Cons:
- $2,000 minimum account
- Platform can feel cluttered
- Mobile app is weaker than competitors
- Less integrated research than Schwab
- Margin rates similar to IBKR
Best strategy: Put spreads, call spreads, iron condors, multi-leg spreads, high-volume selling
Verdict: If you're running 10+ income positions at once, Tastyworks is the only choice. The Greeks visualization and probability tools justify the platform alone.
4. Cboe (Best for Index/VIX Options)
Who it's for: Index options traders, VIX traders, sophisticated volatility plays
Commissions:
- Varies ($0-5 depending on contract)
- SPX / VIX options often cheaper than equity options
Greeks & Tools:
- Excellent for index Greeks
- Volatility surface tools (shows IV across strikes)
- Skew analysis tools
DTE Management:
- Available but not as polished as IBKR/Tastyworks
Pros:
- Official exchange tools (most accurate pricing)
- Best for index-only strategies
- Volatility surface analysis
Cons:
- Not suitable for equity options trading
- Confusing for beginners
- Limited stock/ETF options
Best strategy: Index spreads, SPX / RUT spreads, VIX calls
Verdict: Only if you're trading index options exclusively. For equity income strategies, skip this.
5. Interactive Brokers Lite (Best for Beginners)
Who it's for: Beginners with <$5K accounts, exploring options
Commissions:
- $0 per contract
- $0 per share
Greeks & Tools:
- Basic Greeks (delta, theta shown)
- Limited customization
- Okay for learning, but limited for real trading
DTE Management:
- Basic filtering available
- No advanced sorting
Pros:
- Zero commissions
- Free to use
- Easier platform than full IBKR
- Good for learning
Cons:
- Limited to IBKR lite features
- Greeks tools very basic
- Upgrade to full IBKR requires migration
- Not suitable for advanced strategies
Best strategy: Covered calls on 1-2 stocks, learning the mechanics
Verdict: Great for starting out. But graduate to full IBKR or Schwab once you're serious.
Comparing by Strategy
If You're Selling Covered Calls
Best choice: Charles Schwab
- Simple interface
- Free commissions
- Great for buy-and-hold
- Dividend reinvestment excellent
Runners-up: IBKR, Tastyworks
If You're Doing PMCCs or Multi-Leg Spreads
Best choice: Interactive Brokers
- Best Greeks tools
- Lowest commissions at scale
- Best for managing complexity
Runners-up: Tastyworks (if spreading), IBKR Lite (if budget constrained)
If You're Running the Wheel Strategy
Best choice: Interactive Brokers
- Excellent Greeks (critical for optimal strike selection)
- Lowest costs (wheel involves many trades)
- Best margin rates (you'll likely use margin for CSPs)
Runners-up: Schwab (if low volume), Tastyworks (if high volume)
If You're Selling Put/Call Spreads Actively
Best choice: Tastyworks
- Zero commissions on spreads (you'll do 100+ per month)
- Best Greeks visualization
- Best probability tools
- Community of spread traders
Runners-up: IBKR, Schwab
If You're an Index Options Trader
Best choice: Interactive Brokers
- SPX / RUT options pricing
- Best Greeks tools for indexes
- Excellent margin rates
Runners-up: Cboe (if VIX-specific)
The Cost Analysis: Commission Impact
Let's say you're running 10 income positions per month (a moderate amount). How much does the broker matter?
Scenario: 10 Covered Calls Sold Per Month (CSP Management)
Platform A: Charles Schwab
- 10 positions × $0 commission = $0
- 10 rolls × $0 = $0
- Monthly cost: $0
- Annual cost: $0
Platform B: Interactive Brokers (with volume discount)
- 10 positions × $0.50 = $5
- 10 rolls × $0.50 = $5
- Monthly cost: $10
- Annual cost: $120
Platform C: Old-school broker
- 10 positions × $5 = $50
- 10 rolls × $5 = $50
- Monthly cost: $100
- Annual cost: $1,200
Difference: $0 (Schwab) vs. $120 (IBKR) vs. $1,200 (old broker) annually
Math: For low-volume traders, commission difference is negligible. But if you're running 50+ trades monthly, IBKR saves serious money.
The Margin Rate Impact
If you're using margin (e.g., CSP margin requirements, PMCC buying power), the broker's margin rate matters.
Example: $20,000 CSP position on margin
- IBKR margin rate: 2.5% annually = $500/year
- Schwab margin rate: 4% annually = $800/year
- Difference: $300/year (small but adds up)
For most traders, margin impact is minimal unless you're using significant leverage.
Psychological Factors: Platform Usability
Here's what people don't talk about: a platform you hate using is a platform where you'll make worse decisions.
If you're overwhelmed by IBKR's interface: You might miss Greeks details, avoid rolling positions, or trade impulsively. That's worse than paying Schwab's slightly higher fees.
If Tastyworks' Greeks visualization clicks for you: You might trade more confidently and hit your targets. That's worth the $2K minimum.
Test before committing: Most brokers offer paper trading or free trial accounts. Trade on the platform for a few weeks before funding a real account.
My Recommendation by Account Size & Strategy
$0-5K Account, Beginner
Use: Charles Schwab
- Free, simple, great learning
- Covered calls on 1-2 stocks
- Graduate to IBKR or Tastyworks once account grows
$5-20K Account, Intermediate
Use: Charles Schwab
- Free commissions
- Can run 5-10 income positions
- Great customer support
- Simple platform
Alternative: IBKR Lite if you want slightly better Greeks
$20-50K Account, Intermediate-Advanced
Use: Interactive Brokers
- Commissions now matter (lower fees pay dividends)
- Greeks tools justify the learning curve
- Wheel, PMCC, spreads all optimal
$50K+ Account, Advanced
Use: Interactive Brokers
- Lowest costs at scale
- Best tools and margin rates
- Can run unlimited strategy complexity
Alternative: Tastyworks if spreading is your main focus (zero commissions on spreads)
Hidden Features That Matter
Auto-Roll Functionality
- IBKR: Good auto-roll, customizable
- Schwab: Limited auto-roll
- Tastyworks: Excellent auto-roll for spreads
- Value: Saves time on repetitive rolling
Mobile Options Trading
- Schwab: Best mobile (can sell/buy options on the go)
- IBKR: Okay mobile (limited on app)
- Tastyworks: Weak mobile (desktop-first)
- Value: Important if you trade outside office hours
Tax Lot Tracking
- Schwab: Excellent (integrates with tax software)
- IBKR: Good (detailed but complex)
- Tastyworks: Okay (basic tracking)
- Value: Huge if you're managing 20+ lots annually
Alerts & Notifications
- IBKR: Most flexible (set custom alerts)
- Schwab: Good (standard alerts)
- Tastyworks: Good (prob-focused alerts)
- Value: Saves time on monitoring
Switching Brokers: The Reality Check
Transferring an account is painful:
- ACAT transfer: 1-2 weeks
- Tax lot data: Often incomplete
- Position management: Disrupted during transfer
- Frustration: High
My advice: Choose your broker carefully. Switching costs time and emotional energy. Pick one that works for your strategy, then stick with it for at least 1-2 years.
Final Recommendation
For 90% of options traders: Charles Schwab
- Free, simple, reliable
- Good enough Greeks tools
- Excellent support
- No minimum account
- Perfect for covered calls and CSPs
For spread specialists: Tastyworks
- Zero commissions on spreads
- Best probability visualization
- Ideal for multi-leg management
For advanced pros: Interactive Brokers
- Best tools and lowest costs
- Complex strategies
- Margin optimization
- Worth the learning curve
Pick one. Open an account. Trade for 90 days. Only then decide if you need something else.
The broker isn't the bottleneck. Your trading discipline is. Too many traders waste time optimizing brokers when they should be optimizing their strategy.
Choose a broker, get out of the way, and focus on hitting your trades.
Related Articles
- How to Sell Cash-Secured Puts: Interactive Brokers Walkthrough - Platform-specific execution guide for Interactive Brokers
- Options Greeks Calculator: Interactive Tool & Usage Guide - Greeks tools available on each broker
- Cash-Secured Puts Playbook: DTE Optimization & Assignment Risk - DTE filtering features matter for this strategy
- Covered Calls by Expiration: Weekly vs Monthly Income Comparison - Requires good DTE management tools
- Put Credit Spreads: Risk-Defined Income Strategy - Spreads support critical for this strategy