Days to Expiry — Options Portfolio Tracker logo
Days to Expiry

XLU 21-Day Rule research

Public recipe: cash-secured wheel sized to equity, 35 DTE / 2% OTM puts and calls, manage at 21 DTE. Simulated window 2024-11-15 to 2026-11-13.

Two paired wheel simulations on XLU, one managed at 21 DTE. On this simulation the 21-Day Rule finished -21.3 pp behind holding to expiry — managing early hurt here.

Live broker sync, true cost basis after rolls. No card.

Arm-by-arm comparison

MetricStandard (hold to expiry)21-Day RuleDelta
Total return31.4%10.0%-21.3 pp
Annualized return14.7%4.9%-9.7 pp
Buy-and-hold return11.1%11.1%0.0 pp
Max drawdown (from peak equity)12.6%11.6%-1.0 pp
Assignment rate30.0%31.8%+1.8 pp
Call-away rate25.0%28.0%+3.0 pp
Average cycle return3.1%0.5%—
Sample cycles1022—
History days728728—
Entry fills1847—
Entry fills priced from real option bars44%40%—
21-DTE buy-backs priced from real option bars—38%—

How XLU compares

Across the 39 published tickers, the 21-Day Rule finished ahead of holding to expiry on 16 and behind on 23. The XLU total-return delta of -21.3 pp ranks 38th of 39 (1st is where managing early helped most); the median delta is -2.5 pp.

Without the rule, the standard arm returned 31.4% against 11.1% for buy-and-hold, so the plain wheel beat holding the shares by 20.2 percentage points in this simulation.

Among its defensive, healthcare and income peers LLY, TLT, UNH and XLV, the rule finished ahead of holding to expiry on 1 of 4; XLU itself came in at -21.3 pp.

The separate 10 DTE / 2% OTM wheel snapshot for XLU shows a put assignment rate of 25.9% and wheel P&L of $393 against $441 for buy-and-hold. That is a different recipe from the 35 DTE study on this page, so the two results are not additive.

MetricXLUFamily medianRank (highest first unless noted)
Rule total-return delta-21.3 pp-2.5 pp38th of 39
Rule drawdown delta-1.0 pp-1.9 pp27th of 39 (lowest first)
21-Day total return10.0%12.1%24th of 39
21-Day annualized return4.9%5.9%24th of 39
Standard total return31.4%16.1%6th of 39
21-Day max drawdown11.6%19.9%7th of 39 (lowest first)
21-Day call-away rate28.0%37.5%33rd of 39
Standard annualized return14.7%7.7%6th of 39
Buy-and-hold return11.1%33.1%33rd of 39
Standard max drawdown12.6%19.4%9th of 39 (lowest first)
Standard assignment rate30.0%33.3%27th of 39
21-Day assignment rate31.8%30.4%17th of 39
21-Day sample cycles222734th of 39
21-Day average cycle return0.5%0.5%21st of 39
TickerStandard return21-Day returnRule deltaBuy-and-holdStandard drawdown21-Day drawdownStandard assignment21-Day assignment
XLU31.4%10.0%-21.3 pp11.1%12.6%11.6%30.0%31.8%
LLY41.3%25.6%-15.7 pp93.4%19.4%22.1%30.8%28.1%
TLT5.6%1.8%-3.8 pp-11.9%10.6%9.3%37.5%25.0%
UNH-26.8%-22.8%+4.0 pp-31.2%49.9%46.1%62.5%30.8%
XLV22.2%10.1%-12.1 pp33.1%11.9%8.8%44.4%33.3%

XLU wheel snapshot — the other published study on this ticker.

XLU buy-and-hold path

Month-end P&L of holding 100 XLU shares over the same window as this study, taken from the stored series of the 10 DTE wheel snapshot. The best month for holders was 2026-02 ($448) and the worst was 2024-12 (−$362).

MonthBuy-and-hold P&LChange in monthRunning highBelow its peakWorst fall so far
2024-11$184—$184$0$22
2024-12−$178−$362$184$362$402
2025-01−$69$109$184$253$412
2025-02−$2$67$184$186$412
2025-03−$21−$19$184$205$412
2025-04−$18$3$184$202$492
2025-05$133$151$184$51$492
2025-06$120−$13$184$64$492
2025-07$321$201$321$0$492
2025-08$253−$68$403$150$492
2025-09$398$145$403$5$492
2025-10$492$94$682$190$492
2025-11$569$77$682$113$492
2025-12$306−$263$682$376$492
2026-01$362$56$682$320$492
2026-02$810$448$810$0$492
2026-03$626−$184$810$184$492
2026-04$722$96$810$88$492
2026-05$479−$243$810$331$492
2026-06$571$92$810$239$492
2026-07$472−$99$810$338$492
2026-08$260−$212$810$550$550
2026-09−$19−$279$810$829$848
2026-10$380$399$810$430$848
2026-11$441$61$810$369$848
Problem

A single ticker result is context, not a verdict

One ticker and one window prove nothing general; the rule arm sometimes cannot exit at 21 DTE

Solution

What this paired simulation produced

Window and freshness

Period 2024-11-15 to 2026-11-13, refreshed 2026-11-15.

Limitations

Premiums may include model fills (BSM/IV) when market quotes were missing.
  • Simulated results of one fixed recipe over one historical window; not collected income and not a prediction.
  • The rule arm could not exit at 21 DTE on 0 short options and held those to expiry.
  • Modelled pricing: real option bars priced 44% (standard) and 40% (21-Day) of entry fills and 38% of 21 DTE buy-backs; the rest used implied or realized volatility where market quotes were missing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Everything you need to know about getting started

Did the 21-Day Rule help on XLU?

On this simulation the 21-Day Rule finished -21.3 pp behind holding to expiry — managing early hurt here.

What recipe was simulated?

Same wheel, but the 21-Day arm buys each short option back at 21 DTE; an in-the-money put then takes the shares at that day's close and an in-the-money call delivers them.

Ready to Get Started?

Join traders who are already using our tools to make better decisions.

Live broker sync, true cost basis after rolls. No card.